Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marcus's avatar

Hey Paula,

Representation is definitely a complex topic. I remember an old episode of Oprah's Bookclub. All the women around the table were expressing how shocked, baffled, and excited, they were that the pregnant MC was so believable. Several were mothers. They were shocked and baffled because the author was a man.

Oprah's reviewers were excited because they discovered that a man who could never physically experience what they had, was able to understand them through the power of imagination (and possibly parenthood?).

I'm not sure personal experience is the criteria. I believe it comes down to whether the author is able to imagine themselves in someone else's shoes, or body.

If we create strict rules whereby the author must have experienced the same events or emotions as their characters, then we can kiss goodbye to the powers of imagination. There is no empathy without imagination. We have to venture outside our own experience to understand other people.

(This is a vast topic. Maybe I'll start a thread in the Wattpad forums).

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts